Archive for Quarterbacks

Pre-Season Scouting Report: Matt Barkley

What I like:

Barkley is my pre-season #1 quarterback for the 2013 draft. He’s a prototypical pocket passer who possesses the arm and intelligence to be a top draft pick. He has great accuracy in the short and intermediate game and has adequate arm strength. He plays in a pro-style offense and his mechanics are above average. He’s calm in the pocket and despite not being the best athlete, he can move around well when he feels pressure.

What I don’t like:

His arm is just average. At times his passes can die on him and he doesn’t throw a great deep ball. It’s enough to get the job done but it won’t be bailing him out either. He’s not a great athlete and isn’t much of a threat with his legs. His footwork needs to be cleaned up a bit and he needs to work on driving the ball down-field better. Despite making good decisions overall, he tends to make some bad decisions with pressure in his face.

Outlook:

Barkley should have another good year at USC and while he has some competition for the #1 overall pick, I think he’s got the head start. I can’t imagine him not being a top draft pick in the 2013 draft class.

2012 QB Rankings

These are my 2012 QB Rankings. These are not projections. Click on the players name for a scouting report if one is available.

1. Andrew Luck* – Stanford
2. Robert Griffin III* – Baylor
3. Ryan Tannehill – Texas A&M
4. B.J. Coleman – UT-Chattanooga
5. Brandon Weeden – Oklahoma State
6. Kirk Cousins – Michigan State
7. Kellen Moore – Boise State
8. Russell Wilson – Wisconsin
9. Nick Foles – Arizona
10. Brock Osweiler* – Arizona State

Terrelle Pryor Scouting Report

Height: 6’5
Weight: 240
College: Ohio State
40 Time: 4.55
Class: Junior

*Note: Grades are on a scale of 1 to 5*

Scouting Report:

Arm Strength

Has a strong arm and is capable of making all the throws. He shows the ability to put touch on passes to the flats and knows to zip passes over the middle although he is still inconsistent in this area. Doesn’t have great velocity on his throws however and some of his deep balls tend to float despite his naturally strong arm. This is a mechanical issue as he’s often throwing off his back foot and off-balance. Will dangerously lob deep balls in double coverage that can easily be picked off.

Grade: 2.5

Accuracy

Erratic is a perfect word to describe his accuracy. You will not be an accurate passer unless you have proper mechanics and Pryor does not. He can’t consistently hit receivers in stride. For the most part he throws the ball in the vicinity of the receiver and hope he makes a play. He misses on intermediate routes often and his deep balls are usually jump balls that can go either way. Under pressure his accuracy gets even worse because his footwork gets worse. He’ll need a ton of work on his mechanics before he can become an accurate passer.

Grade: 1.0

Mobility

By far his best asset. Can be dangerous when he takes off with the ball. Has a good burst and has deceptive speed because of his size. His size makes it tough for defensive backs to tackle him and he has showed a pretty nasty stiff arm at times. Does a good job of avoiding sacks in the backfield. Will lower his shoulder to try and pick up the first down. At times falls in love with his ability to run and misses open receivers as a result. Needs to do a better job of securing the ball both in the pocket and when scrambling.

Grade: 4.0

Decision Making

Makes some very bad decisions at times and at best is very inconsistent in this department. Doesn’t usually go through his progressions and will instead look to run if his primary target is not open. Tends to stare down his target until he’s open. Decision making gets even worse when he’s pressured. Will routinely throw off his back foot and off-balance and force passes. He may get away with this in college but he will be a pick machine in the NFL if he does not improve. Commits himself to running before properly scanning the field a lot of times as well. Lacks the proper knowledge of timing routes and really struggles in this area. He doesn’t anticipate throws and throws passes late to open receivers. This again is likely to lead to a lot of interceptions in the NFL.

Grade: 1.0

Mechanics

Very poor overall mechanics. Is experienced taking snaps from under center but still lacks the fundamental footwork for his drop backs. He can’t properly do a 3,5 or 7 step drop back. He takes unnecessary steps when coming out from under center which ultimately slows his drop back and throws off the timing. Is inconsistent with his planting foot and at times will over extend and put his body at an awkward angle ultimately leading to inaccurate passes. Fails to step into his throws and often times just tries to push the ball down field. Drops his elbow upon release but it’s not a major problem to his game.

Grade: 1.0

Pocket Awareness

I was a bit surprised to see that Pryor for the most part handles himself pretty well in the pocket. When he has time he stays in the pocket (although he still has horrendous footwork), but he’s not a much better passer. He still won’t go through his progressions so it really just buys him more time to stare down his receiver and hope he gets open. He can elude sacks and he does have a pretty good feel for pressure. His timing is poor and he still scrambles when he doesn’t have to but he does have some positives to build off of in this area.

Grade: 2.5

Intangibles

Not exactly a saint off the field but hasn’t gotten in trouble with the law. Was part of the scandal at Ohio State and received a 5 game suspension but chose to enter the supplemental draft instead of dealing with the consequences. Known to be immature and his heart and dedication to improve have been questioned. Has recently undergone foot surgery as well. Some say he has the ability to play wide receiver but we don’t know if he’s willing to try it out. It would up his value a little bit to some teams that see potential in a 6’5 WR that runs a 4.5.

Grade: 2.0

Overall Draft Grade – 6th/7th Round

Terrelle Pryor is a project. He’s nowhere near where he needs to be as a passer to have any success in the NFL. As of right now hes a 3rd stringer who you let sit and hope he develops one day. The potential is there but you can barely see the light at the end of the tunnel right now. It will take him at least a year or two in the NFL before he’ll be able to fight for a starting spot. I just don’t see him having much success in the NFL. He’s in the same class as someone like Joe Webb who is an incredible athlete but ultimately might have to move to WR. Webb did everything he was asked to do, even return kicks, and he manged to stick on the roster and ended up getting a shot. That’s the same path Pryor needs to take. If he goes in with a lackadaisical attitude because he thinks he’s a superstar, he won’t last long in this league.

2011 QB Rankings

These rankings are as of March 30, 2011. They are not projections! They are basically my grades and order from best to worst in my opinion, from what I’ve seen of them.

Click for scouting report, if one is available.

Rank Player College Height Weight 40 Time
1 Blaine Gabbert Missouri 6’4 234 4.62
2 Jake Locker Washington 6’3 231 4.59
3 Ricky Stanzi Iowa 6’4 223 4.93
4 Christian Ponder Florida State 6’2 229 4.65
5 Cam Newton Auburn 6’5 248 4.59
6 Colin Kaepernick Nevada 6’5 233 4.53
7 Ryan Mallett Arkansas 6’7 253 5.36
8 Andy Dalton TCU 6’2 215 4.87
9 Greg McElroy Alabama 6’2 220 4.91
10 Nathan Enderle Idaho 6’4 240 5.15
11 Tyrod Taylor Virginia Tech 6’1 217 4.51
12 Pat Devlin Delaware 6’3 225 4.86
13 Scott Tolzien Wisconsin 6’2 212 4.93
14 T.J. Yates North Carolina 6’3 219 5.10
15 Jerrod Johnson Texas A&M 6’5 251 4.80
16 Josh Portis California (PA) 6’3 211 4.62
17 Taylor Potts Texas Tech 6’4 220 4.87
18 Jeff Van Camp Florida Atlantic 6’5 218 4.84
19 Mike Hartline Kentucky 6’5 210 4.90
20 Ryan Colburn Fresno State 6’3 233 5.18